I understand the need for violence in books. I have nothing against it. I'm definitely not one of those people championing for no violent video games for children. But sometimes I wonder if the violence in books serve their purpose anymore. In my opinion, usually it's used to show how awful or evil the antagonist is. Other times even the protagonists have to fight to the death to save their lives.
For example, a few PNR I read in the last few weeks all had some kind of mutilation or torture or dismembering. The protagonist actively engages in torturing his or her enemies for information. Now, I don't want to talk about the right or wrong of torture. It's way beyond what I want to say. The point is, I didn't blink an eye at this. I just didn't care enough. It's all part of the story.
Another good example is when the protagonist walks into a particularly bloody "crime scene". You know, one where there's blood and other stuff splatter all over the walls. This used to bother me a lot, because I hate anything gory, but now I don't even think about it. Now I get really annoyed and always think, "OK, I get it. The bad guy sucks. Now go get him. I don't care about the brains splattered on the floor" or something along those lines.
See what I'm reduced to here? I always feel bad but I can't help it. It's like I'm not paying proper tribute to the people who died, but that's just another problem. Often, with this much violence going on, most of the people who die are not even important. They just show up and die. And we're suppose to feel sad. It doesn't work that way. If I never cared about the character in the first place, his or her death won't mean anything to me.
Maybe I need a break. I switch up my book genres all the time, but now I really need to stay away from books where there're plenty of bloodshed and slaughter, at least until I don't roll my eyes at somebody getting killed.
So what do you think? How do you feel about the ceaseless violence in some books you read? Or do you not even think about it?












9 comments:
Hmmm... well I think Im desensitized to the point that i just read it and accept it and move on. But with torture, if its graphic and well written, sometimes it bothers me. Maybe you should though, just step out of your comfort zone for a little while and read something you wouldnt normally read.
Good point Ning, but I honestly don't even think about it. At first, I was like, "oh wow, that happened??" but I hardly cringed, just shocked mostly. Now I like it >.< Is that bad?? I want there to be violence because like you said, it shows how evil the antagonist is, yeah I agree sometimes there's too much, and some are exaggerated, but it's a necessary evil I suppose *shrugs* :P Lol
I know. I want to be more affected, but because of how often torture or something happens, I kind of just skip through it to get to the good parts. Do I really care if the victim is begging? no. I just want to know if he ends up giving the information lol.
I'm reading some contemporary romance now w/ no violence whatsoever. so hopefully it'll cure me of this
Yeah I agree. It's one reason I like fantasy because though it's violent, it has very interesting villains. But mostly in the romance/PNR/UF books I haven't read a grey villain yet. most are black and white. You know. Oh he massacres ppl. he has an evil laugh. so he's evil! Let's kill him. We kill him. the end. That sort of thing gets boring after a while.
x] Lol yeah that's true. There's no real connection to the villain. No why's or how's, definitely seeing your point on this now :)
Yeah I want a villain I can sympathize with!! even if he's evil I want to fell conflicted about him/her, not just plain hate him because he's annoying and similar to all other villains lol
Lol exactly! if we can't get a sense of why he is the way he is, then it's just pointless to make him a "villain" -__-
I agree! I want more characterization of my villains! Not just a one dimensional psychopath that kills people for fun
i know right! there is always a reason for why people end up the way they do. Nobody's born evil, so not giving us a reason behind the actions, is quite unnerving -____-
Post a Comment